[android] Import Bookmarks and Tracks button does not import Maps.Me bookmarks anymore #5718

New issue

Closed

opened 2023-08-14 05:28:04 +00:00 by biodranik · 0 comments

biodranik commented

2023-08-14 05:28:04 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Maps.Me changed the internal KMB bookmarks format, and without knowing what exactly has changed (Maps.Me is a closed-source app), Organic Maps can't import bookmarks. See also #5638

A possible import workaround is to manually export each bookmark list from Maps.Me (select Share in the menu when you press ... on the left from the list's title), and immediately open it in Organic Maps.

From Android perspective, it's better to properly notify users about the failed import and suggest a workaround.

One of the possible solutions is to reverse-engineer what bytes have changed in KMB and ignore them in our code. For that, an older version of the same bookmark KMB file can be compared with a newer one.

08-13 20:54:52.080 (main) D/BookmarkCategoriesFragment: onActivityResult(): Importing bookmarks from content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks
08-13 20:54:52.083 (main) D/AppBackgroundTracker: onActivityStarted(): onActivityStarted activity = app.organicmaps.bookmarks.BookmarkCategoriesActivity@6ce6b20
08-13 20:54:52.088 (main) I/BaseActivityDelegate: logLifecycleMethod(): BookmarkCategoriesActivity: onStart() activity: app.organicmaps.bookmarks.BookmarkCategoriesActivity@6ce6b20
08-13 20:54:52.089 (main) D/AppBackgroundTracker: onActivityResumed(): onActivityResumed activity = app.organicmaps.bookmarks.BookmarkCategoriesActivity@6ce6b20
08-13 20:54:52.091 (main) I/BaseActivityDelegate: logLifecycleMethod(): BookmarkCategoriesActivity: onResume() activity: app.organicmaps.bookmarks.BookmarkCategoriesActivity@6ce6b20
08-13 20:54:52.092 (main) I/BaseActivityDelegate: logLifecycleMethod(): BookmarkCategoriesActivity: onPostResume() activity: app.organicmaps.bookmarks.BookmarkCategoriesActivity@6ce6b20
08-13 20:54:52.095 (pool-3-thread-1) D/StorageUtils: listContentProviderFilesRecursively(): docId: primary:MapsWithMe/bookmarks/New list.kmb, name: New list.kmb, mime: application/octet-stream
08-13 20:54:52.113 (pool-3-thread-1) W/BookmarkManager: importBookmarksFile(): Downloading bookmarks file content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks/document/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks%2FNew%20list.kmb with file name New list.kmb
08-13 20:54:52.144 (pool-3-thread-1) D/StorageUtils: listContentProviderFilesRecursively(): docId: primary:MapsWithMe/bookmarks/doc.kmb, name: doc.kmb, mime: application/octet-stream
08-13 20:54:52.161 (pool-3-thread-1) W/BookmarkManager: importBookmarksFile(): Downloading bookmarks file content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks/document/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks%2Fdoc.kmb with file name doc.kmb
08-13 20:54:52.179 (pool-3-thread-1) D/StorageUtils: listContentProviderFilesRecursively(): docId: primary:MapsWithMe/bookmarks/My Places.kmb, name: My Places.kmb, mime: application/octet-stream
08-13 20:54:52.191 (pool-3-thread-1) W/BookmarkManager: importBookmarksFile(): Downloading bookmarks file content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks/document/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks%2FMy%20Places.kmb with file name My Places.kmb
08-13 20:54:52.194 (main) D/BookmarkManager: loadBookmarksFile(): Loading bookmarks file from: /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/cache/New list.kmb
08-13 20:54:52.195 (main) D/BookmarkManager: loadBookmarksFile(): Loading bookmarks file from: /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/cache/doc.kmb
08-13 20:54:52.219 (pool-3-thread-1) D/StorageUtils: listContentProviderFilesRecursively(): docId: primary:MapsWithMe/bookmarks/bm.order, name: bm.order, mime: application/octet-stream
08-13 20:54:52.224 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:426 LoadKmlData(): KML Binary deserialization failure: DeserializeException /home/runner/work/organicmaps/organicmaps/kml/serdes_binary.hpp:160, "Incorrect file version."
08-13 20:54:52.225 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:332 LoadKmlFile(): Loading bookmarks failed, file /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/files/bookmarks/New list.kmb1.kml
08-13 20:54:52.232 (main) D/BookmarkManager: loadBookmarksFile(): Loading bookmarks file from: /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/cache/My Places.kmb
08-13 20:54:52.260 (pool-3-thread-1) D/StorageUtils: listContentProviderFilesRecursively(): docId: primary:MapsWithMe/bookmarks/doc1.kmb, name: doc1.kmb, mime: application/octet-stream
08-13 20:54:52.576 (pool-3-thread-1) W/BookmarkManager: importBookmarksFile(): Downloading bookmarks file content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks/document/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks%2Fdoc1.kmb with file name doc1.kmb
08-13 20:54:52.601 (main) D/BookmarkManager: loadBookmarksFile(): Loading bookmarks file from: /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/cache/doc1.kmb
08-13 20:54:52.611 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:426 LoadKmlData(): KML Binary deserialization failure: DeserializeException /home/runner/work/organicmaps/organicmaps/kml/serdes_binary.hpp:160, "Incorrect file version."
08-13 20:54:52.614 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:332 LoadKmlFile(): Loading bookmarks failed, file /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/files/bookmarks/doc.kmb1.kml
08-13 20:54:52.617 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:421 LoadKmlData(): KML Binary reading failure: Reader::SizeException /home/runner/work/organicmaps/organicmaps/coding/file_reader.cpp:127, "313 1 313"
08-13 20:54:52.619 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:332 LoadKmlFile(): Loading bookmarks failed, file /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/cache/My Places.kmb
08-13 20:54:52.742 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:426 LoadKmlData(): KML Binary deserialization failure: DeserializeException /home/runner/work/organicmaps/organicmaps/kml/serdes_binary.hpp:160, "Incorrect file version."
08-13 20:54:52.743 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:332 LoadKmlFile(): Loading bookmarks failed, file /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/files/bookmarks/doc1.kmb1.kml

Maps.Me changed the internal KMB bookmarks format, and without knowing what exactly has changed (Maps.Me is a closed-source app), Organic Maps can't import bookmarks. See also #5638 A possible import workaround is to manually export each bookmark list from Maps.Me (select Share in the menu when you press ... on the left from the list's title), and immediately open it in Organic Maps. From Android perspective, it's better to properly notify users about the failed import and suggest a workaround. One of the possible solutions is to reverse-engineer what bytes have changed in KMB and ignore them in our code. For that, an older version of the same bookmark KMB file can be compared with a newer one. ``` 08-13 20:54:52.080 (main) D/BookmarkCategoriesFragment: onActivityResult(): Importing bookmarks from content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks 08-13 20:54:52.083 (main) D/AppBackgroundTracker: onActivityStarted(): onActivityStarted activity = app.organicmaps.bookmarks.BookmarkCategoriesActivity@6ce6b20 08-13 20:54:52.088 (main) I/BaseActivityDelegate: logLifecycleMethod(): BookmarkCategoriesActivity: onStart() activity: app.organicmaps.bookmarks.BookmarkCategoriesActivity@6ce6b20 08-13 20:54:52.089 (main) D/AppBackgroundTracker: onActivityResumed(): onActivityResumed activity = app.organicmaps.bookmarks.BookmarkCategoriesActivity@6ce6b20 08-13 20:54:52.091 (main) I/BaseActivityDelegate: logLifecycleMethod(): BookmarkCategoriesActivity: onResume() activity: app.organicmaps.bookmarks.BookmarkCategoriesActivity@6ce6b20 08-13 20:54:52.092 (main) I/BaseActivityDelegate: logLifecycleMethod(): BookmarkCategoriesActivity: onPostResume() activity: app.organicmaps.bookmarks.BookmarkCategoriesActivity@6ce6b20 08-13 20:54:52.095 (pool-3-thread-1) D/StorageUtils: listContentProviderFilesRecursively(): docId: primary:MapsWithMe/bookmarks/New list.kmb, name: New list.kmb, mime: application/octet-stream 08-13 20:54:52.113 (pool-3-thread-1) W/BookmarkManager: importBookmarksFile(): Downloading bookmarks file content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks/document/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks%2FNew%20list.kmb with file name New list.kmb 08-13 20:54:52.144 (pool-3-thread-1) D/StorageUtils: listContentProviderFilesRecursively(): docId: primary:MapsWithMe/bookmarks/doc.kmb, name: doc.kmb, mime: application/octet-stream 08-13 20:54:52.161 (pool-3-thread-1) W/BookmarkManager: importBookmarksFile(): Downloading bookmarks file content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks/document/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks%2Fdoc.kmb with file name doc.kmb 08-13 20:54:52.179 (pool-3-thread-1) D/StorageUtils: listContentProviderFilesRecursively(): docId: primary:MapsWithMe/bookmarks/My Places.kmb, name: My Places.kmb, mime: application/octet-stream 08-13 20:54:52.191 (pool-3-thread-1) W/BookmarkManager: importBookmarksFile(): Downloading bookmarks file content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks/document/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks%2FMy%20Places.kmb with file name My Places.kmb 08-13 20:54:52.194 (main) D/BookmarkManager: loadBookmarksFile(): Loading bookmarks file from: /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/cache/New list.kmb 08-13 20:54:52.195 (main) D/BookmarkManager: loadBookmarksFile(): Loading bookmarks file from: /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/cache/doc.kmb 08-13 20:54:52.219 (pool-3-thread-1) D/StorageUtils: listContentProviderFilesRecursively(): docId: primary:MapsWithMe/bookmarks/bm.order, name: bm.order, mime: application/octet-stream 08-13 20:54:52.224 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:426 LoadKmlData(): KML Binary deserialization failure: DeserializeException /home/runner/work/organicmaps/organicmaps/kml/serdes_binary.hpp:160, "Incorrect file version." 08-13 20:54:52.225 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:332 LoadKmlFile(): Loading bookmarks failed, file /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/files/bookmarks/New list.kmb1.kml 08-13 20:54:52.232 (main) D/BookmarkManager: loadBookmarksFile(): Loading bookmarks file from: /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/cache/My Places.kmb 08-13 20:54:52.260 (pool-3-thread-1) D/StorageUtils: listContentProviderFilesRecursively(): docId: primary:MapsWithMe/bookmarks/doc1.kmb, name: doc1.kmb, mime: application/octet-stream 08-13 20:54:52.576 (pool-3-thread-1) W/BookmarkManager: importBookmarksFile(): Downloading bookmarks file content://com.android.externalstorage.documents/tree/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks/document/primary%3AMapsWithMe%2Fbookmarks%2Fdoc1.kmb with file name doc1.kmb 08-13 20:54:52.601 (main) D/BookmarkManager: loadBookmarksFile(): Loading bookmarks file from: /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/cache/doc1.kmb 08-13 20:54:52.611 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:426 LoadKmlData(): KML Binary deserialization failure: DeserializeException /home/runner/work/organicmaps/organicmaps/kml/serdes_binary.hpp:160, "Incorrect file version." 08-13 20:54:52.614 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:332 LoadKmlFile(): Loading bookmarks failed, file /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/files/bookmarks/doc.kmb1.kml 08-13 20:54:52.617 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:421 LoadKmlData(): KML Binary reading failure: Reader::SizeException /home/runner/work/organicmaps/organicmaps/coding/file_reader.cpp:127, "313 1 313" 08-13 20:54:52.619 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:332 LoadKmlFile(): Loading bookmarks failed, file /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/cache/My Places.kmb 08-13 20:54:52.742 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:426 LoadKmlData(): KML Binary deserialization failure: DeserializeException /home/runner/work/organicmaps/organicmaps/kml/serdes_binary.hpp:160, "Incorrect file version." 08-13 20:54:52.743 (Thread-3) W/OMcore: map/bookmark_helpers.cpp:332 LoadKmlFile(): Loading bookmarks failed, file /data/user/0/app.organicmaps/files/bookmarks/doc1.kmb1.kml ```

Rows
Columns