Physiotherapists are not being rendered, nor searchable by name #1050
Closed
opened 2021-08-09 16:59:20 +00:00 by Outlet2048
·
29 comments
No Branch/Tag specified
master
cicd
weblate-i18n
release/2025.04.19
pastk-relnotes
pastk-data
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/android-auto/car-location
ios/pp-for-track-recording
redauburn-patch-1
ios/route-preview-redesign
rt-android-splashscreen-android12
geojson-support
github/fork/Raghaddahi/fix/1566-url-class-bugs
github/fork/rebustj/fix/coredata-crashes
github/fork/hemanggs/zoom-button-fix
github/fork/hemanggs/styles-poi
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/ci/cmake-workflow
beta/ios-hotfix-search
github/fork/sddzhyc/master
ios/search-fix-to-child-vc
github/fork/savsch/feat/android-modal-search
github/fork/RedAuburn/temp-auto-fix
github/fork/RedAuburn/rework-theme-system
github/fork/rimas-kudelis/sound-strings-lt
github/fork/coderang-gk/feature-homescreen-widget-bookmark
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/android/sdk-om
github/fork/FedericoCeratto/reuse-sbom
github/fork/gpesquero/my_location
github/fork/DevarshVasani/DownloadingError-Message
github/fork/DevarshVasani/handle-surface-destruction
github/fork/Strubbl/Strubbl-patch-1
github/fork/RedAuburn/mastodon-bluesky
github/fork/CrazyStevenz/patch-2
ios/update-toast-ui
pastk-generator-genorder
pastk-autogen-subways
github/fork/meenbeese/integrate-sonarcloud
github/fork/dmitrygribenchuk/localization_cleanup
github/fork/coderang-gk/android-transparent-navbar-light-mode
ios/add-icons-to-the-live-activity-widget
github/fork/hemanggs/parse-coordinate-links
github/fork/gpesquero/intermediate_points
ios/fix-search-on-map-tests-for-ipad
release/2025.03.02
github/fork/RedAuburn/always-update-fast
pastk-drape-subways-greying-out
ios/update-search-vc-ui
github/fork/Isira-Seneviratne/AudioManagerCompat
alpha/2025.02.23
crowdin-master
l10n
github/fork/soshial/generate-taginfo-json
github/fork/DeshDeepakKant/ui/improve-description-display-9943
github/fork/hemanggs/increase-touch-area
ios/search-ui-redesign
ios/show-new-search-vc-from-the-route-building
release/2025.01.24
github/fork/savsch/fix/android-pp-bookmark-edit-issue2418
github/fork/renderexpert/remove_gles2
github/fork/Osyotr/windows-unittests
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/android/world-maps-for-all-flavors
github/fork/RedAuburn/splashscreen-android12
drop-appstream-glib
separate-locationservice-lib
github/fork/gpesquero/remove_speed_display
github/fork/zeac/feature/1
github/fork/DeshDeepakKant/fix/building_levels_hint
github/fork/gpesquero/route_plan
github/fork/IsiGebauer/StylingMtbTrails
github/fork/DeshDeepakKant/Mobile-Internet-Settings
release/2025.01.12
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/actions/cpp-codestyle-check
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/clang-format
int/anrdoid-auto/permissions-screen
rt-docs-release-management-principles
generator-wikipedia
generator-actions
generator-subways
ios/enable-cpp-swift-interop
github/fork/map-per/sand
pastk-docs-values
fix-deprecated-atomic-load
rt-docs-communication
rt-docs-collaboration
github/fork/meenbeese/bsdiff
github/fork/meenbeese/karabakh
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/android-auto/location-off
ios/fix-compile-warnings-and-cleanup-unsupported-code
rt-ios-managed-signing
github/fork/IsiGebauer/AllowDirToBeEmpty
ios/fix-ios-test-ci-action-failure
ab-ios-bookmarks-last-category
github/fork/IdeallyGrey/swap-abandoned-disused-rail-rendering
github/fork/meenbeese/atomic-shared-ptr
pastk-docs-teams
qt-3d-preferences
github/fork/TobiPeterG/cur-speed-widget
fix-file-read-exception
fix-track-length-calculation
github/fork/kavikhalique/foreground-crash-fix
github/fork/meenbeese/py-rewrite
pastk-styles-feature-types-migration
release/24.11.27
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/docker/ubuntu-container
alpha/2024.11.26
beta/2024.11.26
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/refactoring/network
github/fork/Ferenc-/cmake-moc-workaround
github/fork/Ferenc-/qt-touchpad-rotate
ab-tests-macro-fixes
ios/track-recording-fifth-bar-button
github/fork/kavikhalique/expand-touch
vng-fix
release/24.11.12
alpha/2024.11.10
vng-langs
github/fork/DevarshVasani/enable-strict-mode
patch-3
release/2024.10.22
alpha/2024.10.22
beta/2024.10.22
github/fork/gpesquero/separators
github/fork/Piaszczysty/route-arrow-fix
place-page-for-tracks-backup
github/fork/RedAuburn/profile-image
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/magic-enums
release/2024.10.08
release/2024.10.04
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/data/resources-refactoring
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/data/move-fonts
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/core/autogenerate-translations
github/fork/shakhat/feature-#7358
alpha/2024.10.01
vng-search
github/fork/gpesquero/drape_locale
beta/2024.09.19
release/2024.09.19
rdb-weblate
release/2024.09.08
github/fork/alnzrv/wikimedia-fix
android/speed-limit-exceed-flag
alpha/2024.09.03
alpha/2024.09.03-ios-track-recording-feature
mb-PendingIntent-requestCode-fix
alpha/2024.08.29
add-timestamps-to-track
ab-ios-crash-on-assert
github/fork/dmfrodrigues/place-panel
github/fork/Tmpod/tmpod-alt-routes
github/fork/zyphlar/hyphenate_interpolated_addresses
alpha/2024.08.25-ios-track-recording-feature
alpha/2024.08.29-ios-track-recording-feature
github/fork/cortadocodes/create-reproducible-build-dockerfile
github/fork/dvdmrtnz/taginfo
github/fork/gpesquero/display_next_stop
android/speed-limit-threshold
android-oauth2-with-browser
release/2024.08.17
changes-from-release
release/2024.08.15
alpha-iOS-Bluetooth
github/fork/RedAuburn/dynamic-sidewalk-name
github/fork/Jean-BaptisteC/linkify_desc
github/fork/Jean-BaptisteC/phone_fab
github/fork/Jean-BaptisteC/download_screen
rdb-cldr-plural-order
ab-unused-code
ab-android-location-fix
recent-track-recorder
ab-cleaner-shutdown
localized_address_ordering
github/fork/gpesquero/speed_class
github/fork/Tmpod/task/improve-clangd-support
ab-android-layer-button-highlight
weblate
release/2024.07.08
alpha/2024.07.25-rtsisyk-ios-test
github/fork/willcohen/camp_pitch
ios-implement-the-recently-deleted-support-to-icloud-sync
recently-deleted-categories-using-postfix
fix-ios-simulator-version
github/fork/SRSAS/systemUIMode
github/fork/RedAuburn/collection_times-support
alpha/2024.07.02
github/fork/alkino/atomic_shared_ptr
vng-test-data
github/fork/fgbg03/user_routes_feature
release/2024.06.02
github/fork/j13m126/german-tone
github/fork/eisams/check_date
ios/undo-for-the-bookmark-deletion
ios/restore-bookmark-by-tap-on-the-map
ios/undo-for-the-bookmark-deletion-with-restoring-by-tap-on-the-map
github/fork/beasmm/feature-#5074
github/fork/catalms/add_stop_feature
revert-7969-pastk-drape-transparent-areas
github/fork/kubahaha/boundary_marker-preset
github/fork/fitojb/patch-1
ab-drape-use-constant-base-font-height
rt-beta
github/fork/krozhdestvenski/bookmark_category_select
vng-alt-routes
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/warnings/unused-parameter
pastk-styles-shared-paths-tune-down
android-auto/8015-8019-8022
github/fork/BrianMerino/master
github/fork/gerion0/gentoo-fixes
pastk-beta-0420
pastk-2generate-paths
ab-fix-shaders-rebuild
ios/fix-drape-failure-during-test-running
ios/add-test-target-terminate
cleanup/base
github/fork/Dinisvgc/bugfix
github/fork/charlie2clarke/overground-icon
ab-max-open-file-limit
weblate-appstore-i18n
2024.03.27-3-android-hotfix
ab-3party-oauthcpp
android-hotfix-24031805
github/fork/gpesquero/test_distance
ab-android-revert-links
github/fork/RedAuburn/no-tts-info
ab-tts-simpler-strings
rt-android-huawei-crash
rt-android-release-2024.03.02
rt-android-release-2024.03.01
ab-ios-release-2024.02.27
ab-from-chars
gplay-android-auto-hotfix
ab-case-folding
rt-store-metadata
ab-buffer-vector-string-view
ab-update-gh-cache-action
rt-android-bookmark-export
osm-oauth2-support
vng-test
github/fork/gpesquero/tts_link
github/fork/Timmy-Tesseract/master
github/fork/ahmetlii/master
github/fork/sklueber/master
rt-geo-links
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/android/lanes-refactoring
vng-lines
windows3
android-auto-disable
rt-android-paranoid-mode
github/fork/TheAdventurer64/juice
rt-android-outdoor
ios-hotfix-release-dec-2023
rt-android-location-providers
pastk-outdoors-hiking-routes
pastk-2generate
pastk-classif-hiking-routes
vng-gen-kk
poc-disable-route-build-zoom
kk2
ab-thread-checker-qt-download-dialog-fix
revert-6461-category-letterbox-it
beta-outdoor
github/fork/pratyaksh1610/branch-6024
protobuf-24.4
designer-fixes
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/core/speed-limit-widget
vng-bookmarks
vng-outdoors
navigation/save-mode
pastk-TEST-rel-w-lines-stats
ab-kml-remove-unique-ptr
vng-bench
aa
rt-android-remove-workmanager
rt-android-debug
protobuf-24.3
pastk-core-housenumbers
github/fork/map-per/pedestrian
ruler-disable-reordering
android-warning-suppress
pastk-drape-bucket-discard-optimization
beta-ios-gpx-fix
github/fork/arnaudvergnet/android-structure-compose
github/fork/arnaudvergnet/compose
github/fork/Nimausfi/new-changes
github/fork/map-per/via_ferrata
pastk-generator-isolines-skip-resimplify
pastk-styles-world-railways
github/fork/kartikaysaxena/master
github/fork/Zhu-Pengming/TomABdh-patch-1
pastk-styles-TMP_dump_priorities
ab-increase-long-tap-radius
github/fork/map-per/track_number
github/fork/codeskraps/feature/nav_altitude_chart
car-checkpoint-tolerance
github/fork/barisunsalhn/fab-transparency
github/fork/N-45div/N-45div/issue4788
rt-android-fix-viewport
github/fork/n1snt/app-shortcuts
github/fork/Kovoschiz/yue4
vng-addr-test
downloader
github/fork/Aryan-Sagavekar/etaswitchfeature
obsolete-position-color
pastk-styles-geometryfallback
pastk-DEMO-geometry-1more-detailed
strings-be-ru-uk-miles
ios/external-keyboard-fix2
alex-outdoors
ios/blue-route-to
pastk-styles-fixpriorities2
pastk-styles-fixpriorities
rt-android-accent-color
pastk-drape-path_text_zoom_mask
pastk-drape-roadshields
update-appstore-metadata
pastk-styles-outdoors
3p/disable-system-jansson
ios/newly-created-list-order
czech-release
rt-fix-monkey-gh
github/fork/AndrewShkrob/core/rendering-on-many-surfaces
github/fork/SiarheiFedartsou/sf-clang-tidy2
ios/fix-tableview-headers-font
github/fork/dvrsaran/patch-1
rt-android-google-location-annoying
pastk-loc-share
ctest
windows2
kml-load-robust
tr-screenshots
vng-nav
github/fork/pastk/pastk-loc-share
github/fork/pratyaksh1610/branch-3621
d4f5409d-patch-1
rt-fix-location-resolution
github-actions-update
android_auto
matheusgomesms-store-releasenotes-pt_BRtranslation
rt-add-ci-timeout
rq-alterRoutes-vng
euskara
github/fork/trueTatar/latlon-refactoring
windows
tests-fix
pastk-styles-geometryfallback-1more-detailed
pastk-styles-zoomlessareas
github/fork/fgaz/changelog/2022.06.29-3
pastk-outdoors-beta
android/R8
github/fork/fardeenfs/public-transit
pastk-android-writability
rt-location-api
pastk-android-verifyerror
qt6
vng-my_pos
pastk-scripts
vng-sdfimage
vng-vehicle-refactoring
release-gp-fdroid-without-location-fixes
rt-android-track-recorder
rt-android-gplay-compliance
rt-android-remove-gms
rt-android-track-recorder-alarm
rt-android-keep-data
fix-odr
github/fork/pastk/pastk-storage
build/no-unity
backup-resources
android/warning-fixes
weblate-ios-i18n
rt-android-symlinks
weblate-android-i18n
weblate-whitespacing
rt-weblate-consume
ios/fixes
i18n-android
i18n-ios
rt-xcode-desktop
2025.04.19-3-android
2025.03.02-7-android
2025.02.17-3-android
2025.01.26-9-android
2024.11.27-12-android
2024.11.12-7-android
2024.10.23-2-android
2024.10.08-5-android
2024.10.04-7-android
2024.09.08-7-android
2024.08.17-4-google-play
2024.08.16-5-android
2024.08.15-21-android
2024.08.15-17-android
2024.07.29-2-android
2024.07.27-7-ios
2024.07.27-8-android
2024.07.23-8-android
2024.07.08-3-android
2024.06.19-3-android
2024.06.02-12-android
2024.05.11-3-android-rc
2024.05.11-3-android
2024.05.10-1-ios
2024.05.04-9-android-rc
2024.05.04-9-android
2024.03.31-8-android-rc
2024.03.31-8-android
2024.03.31-3-android-rc
2024.03.27-3-android-hotfix
2024.03.27-5-android-hotfix
2024.03.18-5-android-hotfix
2024.03.05-4-android
2024.02.06-11-android
2024.02.06-8-android
2024.01.09-5-android
2023.12.20-4-android
2023.12.18-11-android
2023.12.18-10-android
2023.11.17-17-android
2023.09.22-27-android
2023.08.18-8-android
2023.07.13-10-android
2023.06.04-13-android
2023.05.08-7-android
2023.04.02-7-android
2023.03.05-5-android
2023.03.02-3-android
2023.02.13-11-android
2023.01.25-3-android
2022.12.18-12-android
2022.11.24-3-android
2022.11.02-2-android
2022.09.22-3-android
2022.09.15-5-android
2022.08.23-5-android
2022.07.27-3-android
2022.07.01-6-android
2022.06.29-3-android
2022.06.18-2-android
2022.05.31-10-android
2022.05.24-2-android
2022.05.20-5-android
2022.05.20-4-android
2022.05.19-4-android
2022.04.27-2-android
2022.03.23-4-android
2022.02.19-1-android
2022.02.16-29-android
2022.02.11-17-android
2022.01.15-3-android
2022.01.12-6-android
2022.01.12-3-android
2021.12.01-4-android
2021.11.04-2-android
2021.10.22-10-android
2021.10.15-15-android
2021.10.09-2-android
2021.10.08-0-ios
2021.09.14-4-android
2021.09.01-6-android
2021.08.26-13-ios
2021.08.26-14-android
2021.08.19-11-android
2021.08.19-6-android
2021.08.14-4-android
2021.08.09-1-ios
2021.08.07-4-ios
2021.08.05-2-android
2021.08.04-3-ios
2021.07.08-3
2021-07-03
2021.07.04-2
2021-06-23
2021-06-20
2021-06-12
2021-06-07
2021-05-21
2021-05-08
2021-05-05
2021-04-24
Labels
Clear labels
Accessibility
Address
Android
Android Auto
Android Automotive (AAOS)
API
AppGallery
AppStore
Battery and Performance
Blocker
Bookmarks and Tracks
Borders
Bug
Build
CarPlay
Classificator
Community
Core
CrashReports
Cycling
Desktop
DevEx
DevOps
dev_sandbox
Directions
Documentation
Downloader
Drape
Driving
Duplicate
Editor
Elevation
Enhancement
Epic
External Map Datasets
F-Droid
Fonts
Frequently User Reported
Fund
Generator
Good first issue
Google Play
GPS
GSoC
iCloud
Icons
iOS
Legal
Linux Desktop
Linux packaging
Linux Phone
Mac OS
Map Data
Metro
Navigation
Need Feedback
Night Mode
NLnet 2024-06-281
No Feature Parity
Opening Hours
Outdoors
POI Info
Privacy
Public Transport
Raw Idea
Refactoring
Regional
Regression
Releases
RoboTest
Route Planning
Routing
Ruler
Search
Security
Styles
Tests
Track Recording
Translations
TTS
UI
UX
Walk Navigation
Watches
Web
Wikipedia
Windows
Won't fix
World Map
No labels
Accessibility
Address
Android
Android Auto
Android Automotive (AAOS)
API
AppGallery
AppStore
Battery and Performance
Blocker
Bookmarks and Tracks
Borders
Bug
Build
CarPlay
Classificator
Community
Core
CrashReports
Cycling
Desktop
DevEx
DevOps
dev_sandbox
Directions
Documentation
Downloader
Drape
Driving
Duplicate
Editor
Elevation
Enhancement
Epic
External Map Datasets
F-Droid
Fonts
Frequently User Reported
Fund
Generator
Good first issue
Google Play
GPS
GSoC
iCloud
Icons
iOS
Legal
Linux Desktop
Linux packaging
Linux Phone
Mac OS
Map Data
Metro
Navigation
Need Feedback
Night Mode
NLnet 2024-06-281
No Feature Parity
Opening Hours
Outdoors
POI Info
Privacy
Public Transport
Raw Idea
Refactoring
Regional
Regression
Releases
RoboTest
Route Planning
Routing
Ruler
Search
Security
Styles
Tests
Track Recording
Translations
TTS
UI
UX
Walk Navigation
Watches
Web
Wikipedia
Windows
Won't fix
World Map
Milestone
Clear milestone
No items
No milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No items
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
No assignees
2 participants
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference: organicmaps/organicmaps#1050
Reference in a new issue
No description provided.
Delete branch "%!s()"
Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?
(healthcare:physiotherapist)
Thanks! We didn't add any of healthcare tags yet, because of the focus on travelers. Any ideas about where to find good icons for it and which other healthcare tags should be rendered?
So far Organic Maps does render the amenity:doctor tag and even displays an icon for it.
But theres also healthcare:doctor and that should probably rendered as well.
I dont know where you got that icon from but there might be more like it / just re-using the doctor icon seems fine as well
The following are the healthcare tags I'd render, taken from https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:healthcare
healthcare=dentist
healthcare=doctor
healthcare=hospital
healthcare=blood_donation
healthcare=clinic
healthcare=physiotherapist
healthcare=psychotherapist
healthcare=sample_collection
healthcare=speech_therapist
healthcare=vaccination_centre
Everything else is less relevant (to me) and could be rendered with a generic icon, if even
let me know what you think :)
Thanks! Can you please share, what is your main use-case/interest in having these features on the map?
And besides all of that, not limiting Organic Maps purely to a traveler map would be something that im in favor of
A swiss army knife of maps sounds much nicer than having multiple maps apps for whatever it is that I want in that moment
Would it make sense to make these tags searchable but not rendering them on the map?
I am thinking of larger cities where the map could be cluttered by too many POIs. Such specialists are rarely searched by randomly panning a map and are less important as waypoints since they are not as visible (in Europe you will often have a small sign next to a normal looking door, as opposed to restaurants or stores which are very visible and can be used to communicate a certain location)
Would be looking weird if you're able to find something while searching, then click on it and then it just zooms to an area without icon.
And it wouldnt clutter the map if you just hide some less relevant POIs until you zoom in further. When zooming in, I'd like to see all POIs, otherwise i wouldnt zoom in that far.
Also makes exploring the area around you a lot more pleasant
Haha yeah, that would be weird.
But for the cluttering, in some places in Paris there are 8+ different doctors at each house number. It would be important that some POIs (the ones which are easy recognisable from the street and are more often searched by panning the map) are prioritised over others as it might be impossible to render all of them
What about not rendering the healthcare POIs unless searched for? But yes, at least prioritize others.
I believe organic maps is already doing that as of right now. If there are too many POIs in a given area, then only one will be displayed until the user zooms in. This also applies to completely different POIs.
So I guess there's already a solution to the issue in the app. It's just a matter of what POI should be ranked higher if all POIs in the area share the same tag.
See my answer to that question in the reply above
(#1050 (comment))
mentioned in issue #1917
+1 on this. As someone who uses these types of facilities, I would much appreciate this being added. For now, I think just a simple healthcare icon would be great. Maybe in the future, better icons can be added.
Physiotherapist will be added with #3844.
Regarding the other healthcare tags:
healthcare=dentist
,healthcare=doctor
,healthcare=hospital
andhealthcare=clinic
should only be used in combination with the tagamenity=<value>
, thus they will be rendered already by the amenity type.Regarding the rest:
I copied the table of the
healthcare
tags and removed every value which has a count below 1000. (source)IMHO
alternative
andpsychotherapist
are the more interesting ones to be added.I will think of an icon that could be used, in general I would not reuse the doctors icon, as they are a different kind of medical institution.
For
blood_donation
,optomist
,podiatrist
andspeach_therapist
I have simple icons in mind, which feature a drop, eye, foot and lips in a red circle, similar to the doctors icon. I will create a mockup for them, but it still needs to be decided whether the tags will even be added.Thanks for your work! I would also add some types that are more rare, but still are often needed/used by people, even with some kind of generic icon (or even without an icon, just to be searchable).
When it is easy to add a missing POI to the map, some rare types may become more popular.
So I created some icons, let's discuss them.
Please let me know what you think, I am happy for every feedback.
And don't hesitate to let me know if you dislike something.
General icon
For all other categories I had no good ideas on how to express the place as an icon.
So I thought of an generic icon and came up with these two ideas.
I prefer the first one, as the second one looks like love or something is involved because of the hearth.
Your icons are good, but they won't be recognisable on devices with smaller screens. It would be great to simplify them as much as possible and enlarge the central part. The minimum supported resolution now is 18x18 pixels. Try to render it and see if it looks recognizable.
Also, man and woman look similar to a toilet...
Reduced details and simplified them.
IMO way better to identify them.
Below you see the parts at different seizes. (from what I saw are the common ones used in OM)
Feedback is welcome
I think the ear is recognizable
But I can't seem to find a beard in this speech therapist one
Looks more like a open mound to me
Beard is a wrong word ) It looks non-human.
I'll have a look on how to improve it.
Right now laboratory uses the hospital icon (red cross), but the new
sample_collection
icon could be used for the laboratory.I'll create some variations for it (round bottom, filled, multiple tubes.
But I think multiple tubes might be to small in the end... lets see.
Good question :D, at the moment I am out of ideas for this one
Would you prefer something like this, with the whole head filled?
(just an extra quick mockup)
Noted will do so when icons are ready and I add them.
I would stick to the high tube, as the shape in your picture is already used for
chemist
. Furthermore the small high ones are more common for blood and urine samples (based on an image search).Here are some variations:
Speaking for my self I like the third one the most.
Head with just the face and rest cutoff looks weird to me.
Had the idea to make one third of the icon the head, while I like it, it is very different from other icon styles.
Third one is a way simplified version, maybe this is even enough.
Thanks for your efforts, that's so easy to compare now )
We can move on, and then improve icons based on real feedback. I hope these icons also look great in a dark style.
Okay perfect.
I'll get my hands on it on the weekend.
assigned to
@Mr-Mime
mentioned in merge request !4053
mentioned in issue #4660